Introduction
On 22 October 2026, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) published consultation papers[1] setting out their long-awaited Phase 2 proposals for reforming the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR). Together, the proposals represent the most substantial change to the SM&CR since it was introduced in 2016 and is arguably the biggest simplification of the rulebook since the secondary growth and competitiveness objective was introduced. Both regulators are consulting until 22 January 2027 and expect to publish final rules in H1 2027 and implement them six months later in H2 2027.
The reforms form part of the Government’s Financial Services Growth and Competitiveness Strategy (Strategy), which sets a shared ambition between the Government, the FCA and the PRA. That ambition is to reduce the regulatory burden of the SM&CR by 50% and to cut by 40% the number of roles at banks and insurers that require approval, while maintaining robust individual accountability.
Phases 1 and 2
The Phase 2 proposals build on Phase 1 reforms that the regulators introduced earlier this year. In April 2026 the regulators issued policy statements[2] setting out their final Phase 1 rules, making changes that did not need new legislation, so that firms could benefit sooner. Phase 1 was limited, however, because so much of the SM&CR sits in legislation (the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA 2000)). The Phase 2 proposals go much further and are dependent on the Financial Services and Markets Bill becoming law. The Bill would remove many prescriptive SM&CR requirements from primary legislation and would give the regulators the power to apply them through their own rules. The new flexibility includes the power to designate notified (rather than pre-approved) Senior Manager Functions (SMFs) and to remove the statutory basis for the Certification Regime. The regulators are consulting now so that rules can be made soon after the Bill receives Royal Assent. As for the Bill itself, its passage through Parliament is quite advanced. Having already passed through the Lords it is currently awaiting second reading in the Commons.
Linkage to growth and competitiveness
The two consultations also have a wider significance. CP14/26 is the first major policy package of Katherine Braddick’s time as PRA CEO, and it was published on the same day as her Mansion House speech. In our view, the proposals send a strong signal to the market of how important the PRA’s secondary objective of growth and competitiveness is to her. Both regulators expect their combined proposals to deliver the Strategy’s targets.
Key proposals
The regulators have sought to align their proposals as far as possible to reduce complexity for dual-regulated firms. The main common ground is as follows.
SMF notification
Some SMF roles would no longer need pre-approval; firms would notify the regulator instead. SMF5, SMF10, SMF11, SMF12 and SMF14 would become notified under both regimes. The FCA would also make SMF13 (Chair of the Nomination Committee) and SMF15 (Chair of the With-Profits Committee) notified, as these are FCA functions at dual-regulated firms. The PRA would additionally make further roles notified, including SMF6 (Head of Key Business Area), SMF20 (Chief Actuary) and SMF20a (With-Profits Actuary).
Notified SMFs would be held to the same standards as their pre-approved counterparts, including the Duty of Responsibility, the requirement to take reasonable steps and the Senior Manager Conduct Rules. Because the regulator would no longer assess candidates before appointment, vetting falls entirely on the firm. Before submitting a notification, the firm must be satisfied that the candidate is fit and proper and complete checks as for an approved role, including, where required, regulatory references, criminal records checks, right-to-work confirmation and preparation of a Statement of Responsibilities (SoR).
Responsibility for this vetting would sit with the holder of Prescribed Responsibility A (PR A)[3]. The PRA intends to clarify that PR A expressly covers the firm’s vetting of SMF candidates and adds guidance to Supervisory Statement (SS) 28/15 and SS35/15 on the importance of fit and proper assessments being carried out to appropriate standards. The FCA proposes to amend the wording of PR A to clarify the holder’s duties regarding vetting, SMF notifications and SMF applications. The PRA sees this PR A accountability as a key mitigant of the safety and soundness risks of moving to notification. The FCA has said that if firms make unsuitable appointments or fail to apply appropriate scrutiny, it may consult on reintroducing pre-approval.
The Chief Operations Function (SMF24) keeps pre-approval because operational risks, including those arising from AI and cyber incidents, have made effective operational oversight more important. The FCA and PRA intend to review jointly, two years after the Phase 2 proposals are implemented, whether pre-approval for SMF24 is still needed. The review will consider how the risk environment has changed and which responsibilities may fall within the role.
A simple notification process
A notification can be sent to the relevant regulator up to three months before the start date: to the FCA for FCA-designated functions and to the PRA for PRA-designated functions. The FCA intends to carry out only automated checks on notifications, for example that the form is complete and the individual is not prohibited, while the PRA will set out its notification requirements in a PRA direction published on its website.
A notification to the PRA does not need to be copied to the FCA, and no FCA consent is needed for it to take effect. For immediate appointments, the notification will become effective on the date the regulator acknowledges receipt. If the firm submits the notification in advance, it will become effective on the specified start date. The notification would contain only the candidate’s details, confirmation that the fit and proper assessment has been done, and the SoR and Management Responsibilities Map (MRM) where needed.
Both regulators are proposing transitional arrangements in the sense that firms can continue to submit SMF applications until the new rules come into force. This includes for roles that will become notified functions. Where an appointment will take effect after the new rules on SMF notification come into force, firms could submit notifications up to 1 month before commencement.
Pre-approval in exceptional cases
Both regulators would rarely use their own-initiative requirement powers (s.55M FSMA 2000 for the PRA, s.55L FSMA 2000 for the FCA) to require pre-approval for a notified role. They give largely the same examples: serious governance concerns, doubts about a firm’s ability to assess fitness and propriety, or a role of particular importance to the firm’s safety and soundness. The PRA adds a further example of a firm at risk of failing.
Temporary cover
The 12-week rule becomes an 18-week rule. The regulators want to give firms more flexibility to manage temporary or unexpected SMF absences, particularly for pre-approved roles, and more time to find and appoint a permanent candidate without rushing the recruitment process. The FCA notes that the risk of an unsuitable individual acting for longer is offset by the planned cut in the statutory deadline for deciding SMF applications from three months to two, so the overall time someone can act without approval stays broadly the same.
Permitted conditional applications
Firms could apply for time-limited or conditional approval without triggering statutory notices. Time-limited approvals are aimed mainly at interim appointments, for example where recruiting a permanent replacement for a pre-approved SMF is likely to take longer than the 18-week temporary cover period; the PRA would add illustrative examples to Statement of Policy 4/15. Under the FCA’s draft rules, only dual-regulated firms, Enhanced firms and solo-regulated firms in dual-regulated groups could apply, and both regulators expect such requests to be rare.
SoRs and MRMs
Both regulators propose to end the routine submission of updated SoRs and MRMs, including following significant changes to a Senior Manager’s responsibilities, and to withdraw Form J. Firms would, however, remain obliged to keep these documents up to date internally and to provide them to the regulators on request. The FCA’s consultation paper also contains commentary regarding retaining superseded versions.
Certification
The Certification Regime is removed, together with regulatory references for previously certified staff. Firms would no longer need to assess and certify these staff on appointment and every year, but they remain responsible for ensuring the staff are competent and suitable under existing requirements. The Individual Conduct Rules continue to apply to them, and the regulators can still take enforcement action against them. The PRA would also extend its “competent employee” rule to cover integrity and honesty. Firms can still use employment references or other checks when recruiting.
In its consultation paper the FCA notes that removing the Certification Regime represents a significant change to the current framework and could introduce risks. As such it invites views on alternative approaches that would retain beneficial elements of the regime. For example keeping some or all requirements of the Certification Regime, for a subset of the 8 certification functions.
Breach reporting
The reporting threshold rises from a formal written warning to a final written warning for most non-SMF staff (FCA) and for individuals in roles previously within the Certification Regime (PRA). Reporting for SMFs is unchanged.
Mind the gap: where the two regimes part company
Several differences remain that dual-regulated firms will need to manage. These include those set out below.
Temporary absence
Under both regimes, temporary cover is currently available only where an SMF’s absence is temporary or reasonably unforeseen. For PRA functions at dual-regulated firms, the PRA keeps that test to uphold its expectations on succession planning. It expects the full 18 weeks to be used only where there is clear justification, and it will add guidance on documenting temporary cover arrangements. The FCA would remove the “reasonably unforeseen” requirement for FCA solo-regulated firms and FCA functions at dual-regulated firms, because it is hard to apply in practice. The rule would then apply whether an absence is foreseen or unexpected, subject to a new “reasonable use” rule based on Phase 1 guidance. A key question is whether the firm could reasonably have been expected to have contingency plans in place to get a replacement approved in time, taking account of how much notice it had. The FCA asks whether the revised standard should apply to FCA SMFs at dual-regulated firms as well, so dual-regulated firms could face two different tests for the same absence.
Breach reports
Breach reports to the PRA must still be made within seven business days. The FCA would allow up to 14 months.
SMF 7
The PRA proposes to split SMF7 (Group Entity Senior Manager) into an approved role (SMF7 Approved Group Entity Senior Manager) and a new notified SMF7a (Notified Group Entity Senior Manager), without expanding the overall SMF7 population. An individual who performs a group-level role and exercises significant influence would need to be pre-approved if their group role corresponds to certain PRA or FCA pre-approved functions, most relevantly Group Chief Executive, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Risk Officer, Chief Operations Officer, Chief Compliance Officer, Money Laundering Reporting Officer and Board Chair. All other SMF7s become notified SMF7a roles.
Firms must look at the substance of the group role rather than the job title. The PRA considers that SMF7s in branches or subsidiaries of overseas banks will often fall within SMF7a. Individuals already approved as SMF7 before implementation would not need a new application or notification: their existing approval would continue to cover whichever role they fall into, whether the approved SMF7 or the notified SMF7a.
The FCA would narrow SMF7 at solo-regulated firms to individuals who both exercise significant influence and perform one of the specified functions. Individuals who meet only the significant influence test would no longer be SMFs, and the FCA expects the solo-regulated SMF7 population to fall by about 40%. It does not create a notified equivalent.
Prescribed responsibilities
The PRA proposes to keep a longer list of prescribed responsibilities, so some current joint prescribed responsibilities become PRA-only.
FCA proposals with no PRA equivalent
It would remove SMF18 and SMF22, retire the Directory, replace Conduct Rules training with a duty to notify staff of the rules, and bring sole traders within its Code of Conduct.
The FCA would also raise the Enhanced firm thresholds. The thresholds would rise from £130m to £200m revenue for consumer credit lenders, from £65bn to £100bn of assets under management for asset managers, and from £45m to £75m revenue for intermediaries. For wholesale markets firms, the Significant SYSC test[4] would be replaced with a simpler £750m asset threshold, calculated as a three-year rolling average and indexed to inflation. The mortgage and client asset thresholds would be unchanged.
The FCA would also add guidance allowing it to require a firm below the thresholds to comply with the Enhanced regime, taking account of its size, complexity or market impact and whether it would meet the thresholds on a group basis. Firms that cease to be Enhanced would remain subject to the Core regime. The PRA, for its part, would extend its “competent employee” rule so that CRR and Solvency II firms must assess the integrity and honesty of staff previously in scope of certification.
The cost benefit analysis
The FCA expects its proposals to cut annual compliance costs by £229.0m (around 53%), with a ten-year net present value of £1.91bn. The PRA expects a central annual saving of £11.5m (47%). In both analyses most of the saving comes from removing certification. The Senior Managers Regime reforms deliver little measurable saving, and notification is valued at just £0.28m by the FCA.
Conclusion
The Phase 2 proposals are a deliberate rebalancing of the regime. They keep regulatory scrutiny for the most senior executive roles and moves responsibility for much of the rest onto firms.
This rebalancing ties back to the growth and competitiveness agenda that frames the reforms. The PRA argues that notification will make senior appointments faster, more flexible and more predictable. In its view, that will make it easier to attract senior talent, including from overseas, and will support labour mobility. The PRA also expects lower compliance costs to reduce barriers to operating and expanding in the UK. The FCA suggests that resources released from compliance could be redirected towards investment and innovation. It adds that a more efficient regime should support competition, particularly for smaller firms with less formal compliance functions. Both regulators expect the reforms to make the UK a more attractive place to invest and do business.
The savings come at a price, however. Once regulators no longer check candidates before appointment, supervisors will look more closely at firms’ own governance and vetting. Serious concerns about a firm’s ability to assess fitness and propriety are expressly one of the grounds on which a firm could lose the right to notify. Firms that treat the Phase 2 reforms purely as deregulation risk may find themselves under greater, not lesser, scrutiny.
Five practical steps for firms
- Engage with the consultations. Consider the proposals carefully and respond by 22 January 2027 where they affect your business, including on areas where the FCA and PRA approaches still differ and on the assumptions behind the cost benefit analyses.
- Map your SMF population. Identify which current and planned appointments will become notified and plan pending applications around the transition. Notifications can be sent up to one month before commencement, and applications still undecided at that point will continue under the existing process.
- Strengthen vetting and PR A governance. Update fitness and propriety procedures, criminal records and reference checks, and how decisions are recorded, so the PR A holder can show robust oversight of notified appointments.
- Redesign arrangements below the Senior Manager level. Decide what will replace certification internally. This includes ongoing competence and integrity assessments under the extended PRA competent employee rule and FCA SYSC guidance, a revised approach to Conduct Rules training and communication, and processes for the new breach reporting thresholds.
- Refresh accountability documents and budget for change. Review SoRs, MRMs and Prescribed Responsibility allocations, keeping in mind the removal of PRs and of SMF18 and SMF22. Plan for the one-off change costs both regulators expect, with implementation expected in H2 2027.
[1] FCA CP26/37 and PRA CP14/26
[2] FCA PS26/6 and PRA PS12/26
[3] PR A is the Prescribed Responsibility for the firm’s performance of its obligations under the Senior Managers Regime. It must be allocated to a Senior Manager and, under the FCA’s draft rules, includes compliance with conditions and time limits on approvals and SMF notifications; compliance with the requirements on MRMs and SoRs; the firm’s obligations under section 60A FSMA 2000 to vet SMF candidates; compliance with the regulatory references rules as they relate to the Senior Managers Regime; and the firm’s obligations on SMF applications, notifications and variations. The PRA proposes to clarify that its equivalent PR A also covers the firm’s vetting of candidates for senior management functions.
[4] A “significant SYSC firm” is defined in SYSC 1.5 of the FCA Handbook by reference to size thresholds that include a balance sheet assets element, currently £530m. Under the current SM&CR rules, a MiFID investment firm that is a significant SYSC firm and meets certain additional criteria is an Enhanced firm. The FCA proposes to replace that test for SM&CR purposes with a single £750m asset threshold, while leaving the significant SYSC firm definition itself unchanged for other requirements that rely on it.




